The Nylon Curtain (1982) is arguably Billy Joel's finest album. It is a collection of songs directly inspired by the Beatles and the bittersweet realities of the Reagan era.
The opener ,"Allentown," is a lament about the economic issues that plagued the Midwest in the 1980s. Joel writes about the high unemployment and the declining expectations of the new generation, "every child had a pretty good shot of getting at least far as their old man got/but something happened on the way to that place and they threw an American flag in our face."
In a similar vein is "Goodnight Saigon," his only direct song about the Vietnam War. By the 1980s the passions of the had diminished and the narrative of the began to change. President Reagan, who called the conflict a "noble war," moved Americans to forget the painful politics of the era and placed emphasis on the sacrifice of the soldiers. Popular films like The Deer Hunter and First Blood were examples of the shift in attitude on Vietnam by avoiding the politics of the era. The song is written from the point of view of a soldier on the ground who did his duty in spite of the horrible conditions he faced. Joel also avoided the politics and wrote about remembering those who continue to struggle after the war - very much in the tone of All Quiet on the Western Front.
Other highlights include "Laura", "Surprise, Surprise," and "Scandinavian Skies." On "Laura" Joel channels the spirit of John Lennon (even sounds like him) in a song similar to "Sexy Sadie" and "I'm So Tired" from the White album. Meanwhile, "Surprise, Surprise" is a nod to Wings era McCartney. One of the hidden gems in Joel's catalogue, "Scandinavian Skies," is a cryptic song about a haunting tour through Europe. Is it about the travails of touring? On closer reading there are references to holocaust (Joel's father was a survivor), punctuated by the haunting strings, in lyrics like "The Sins of Amsterdam were still a recent surprise" and "the tour of Germany Was bleeding into our eyes." The pristine sound of the song captures the majesty of European civilization, but also the darkness that lays beneath all the "culture" of Europe.
Whatever one's opinion of Joel's later career and the fact he has not made an album since 1993, it remains a soundtrack for the baby boom generation. His later albums moved away from social commentary to banal pop songs, devoid of the adventurous production in The Nylon Curtain. Perhaps MTV is to blame for destroying the singer-songwriter era and putting image above all else. Some flourished in this environment, but most did not. But that's another story.
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Wednesday, December 15, 2010
Book Review: Kardiac Kids: The Story of the 1980 Cleveland Browns by Jonathan Knight
Red Right 88. Those words continue to send chills down the spines of Cleveland Brown fans. On a frigid January day at old Cleveland Stadium, the Browns were on the verge of victory in a divisional playoff game with the Oakland Raiders when quarterback Brian Sipe threw an interception that ended their season. Jonathan Knight's comprehensive account of that season recaptures one of the most exciting years in Cleveland sports. For three seasons (1978-80), the "Kardiac Kids," consistently pulled off dramatic victories in the closing minutes of their games. The book makes it clear that while 1980 Browns came up short in the end - they provided their fans with an unforgettable ride that continues to resonate to this day.
During the 1950s, the Cleveland Browns were the premiere franchise of the NFL. They were a dynasty that won five world championships (this was the pre-Super Bowl era) with a legendary corps of Hall of Famers like head coach Paul Brown, Marion Motley, Otto Graham, and arguably the greatest football player ever - Jim Brown. In 1964 the Browns trounced the Baltimore Colts 27-0 for yet another championship that few realized at the time - would be their last. During the 1970s the Browns struggled after a series of bad trades, lackluster draft picks, and injuries. Cleveland fans were forced to sit back and watch as their division rival the Pittsburgh Steelers went on to win four Super Bowls.
In 1978, things began to turn around when Browns owner Art Modell hired Sam Rutigliano as head coach. A longtime assistant coach, Rutigliano revitalized the Browns by building an explosive offense behind the accurate passing of veteran quarterback Brian Sipe. After a promising 8-8 season in 1979, it appeared the Browns were heading in the right direction for 1980. And they would not disappoint. Cleveland, a tough blue collar town, faced high unemployment, racial and ethnic tensions, and a constant target of comedians who taunted their town as the "mistake by the lake," desperately needed something positive to happen for their city. While it is a cliche that a winning football team will not revitalize a city overnight, it can do much to lift the spirits of people experiencing tough times.
Knight provides a detailed account of every game and some of the drama that went on behind the scenes. Unlike other "insider" accounts of professional sports, they generally seemed like a good group of guys. Rutigliano was true players' coach who was respected for his intelligence and willingness to roll the dice when the time called for it. The 1980 Browns were a veteran team with many players in their prime of their careers. Lyle Alzado, an acquisition from the Denver Broncos, had a reputation as a loose cannon, but his enthusiasm added a spark to the defense. Newcomers like tight end Ozzie Newsome and linebacker Clay Matthews made great contributions and went on to become Hall of Famers. Brian Sipe, however, was the leader and rock of the Kardiac Kids who always gave his team a chance to win in the clutch. He continues to hold most of the passing records for the Browns franchise.
The heartbreaking 14-12 loss to the Raiders ended an era. In 1981, they fell to 5-11 and went on to suffer a succession of losing seasons. By 1985, the year the Browns returned to the playoffs, only six players remained from the 1980 squad. Although the Browns went deeper into the playoffs later in the decade (they lost three AFC championships to the Denver Broncos) the heroics of the Kardiac Kids remain etched in the memories of Browns fans. Knight did a great job in recapturing the excitement of that year. The Browns reminded their fans that hard work and a "never say die" attitude can make anything possible.
During the 1950s, the Cleveland Browns were the premiere franchise of the NFL. They were a dynasty that won five world championships (this was the pre-Super Bowl era) with a legendary corps of Hall of Famers like head coach Paul Brown, Marion Motley, Otto Graham, and arguably the greatest football player ever - Jim Brown. In 1964 the Browns trounced the Baltimore Colts 27-0 for yet another championship that few realized at the time - would be their last. During the 1970s the Browns struggled after a series of bad trades, lackluster draft picks, and injuries. Cleveland fans were forced to sit back and watch as their division rival the Pittsburgh Steelers went on to win four Super Bowls.
In 1978, things began to turn around when Browns owner Art Modell hired Sam Rutigliano as head coach. A longtime assistant coach, Rutigliano revitalized the Browns by building an explosive offense behind the accurate passing of veteran quarterback Brian Sipe. After a promising 8-8 season in 1979, it appeared the Browns were heading in the right direction for 1980. And they would not disappoint. Cleveland, a tough blue collar town, faced high unemployment, racial and ethnic tensions, and a constant target of comedians who taunted their town as the "mistake by the lake," desperately needed something positive to happen for their city. While it is a cliche that a winning football team will not revitalize a city overnight, it can do much to lift the spirits of people experiencing tough times.
Knight provides a detailed account of every game and some of the drama that went on behind the scenes. Unlike other "insider" accounts of professional sports, they generally seemed like a good group of guys. Rutigliano was true players' coach who was respected for his intelligence and willingness to roll the dice when the time called for it. The 1980 Browns were a veteran team with many players in their prime of their careers. Lyle Alzado, an acquisition from the Denver Broncos, had a reputation as a loose cannon, but his enthusiasm added a spark to the defense. Newcomers like tight end Ozzie Newsome and linebacker Clay Matthews made great contributions and went on to become Hall of Famers. Brian Sipe, however, was the leader and rock of the Kardiac Kids who always gave his team a chance to win in the clutch. He continues to hold most of the passing records for the Browns franchise.
Sunday, October 3, 2010
Book Review: Bob Dylan in America by Sean Wilentz

In each chapter Wilentz traces the origins of the cultural influences on Dylan that span all the eras of American history - starting with Aaron Copeland. Copeland's mixing of classical with folk music marked a precursor to Dylan who blended high and low art. Although often considered one of the primary icons of the 1960s, Wilentz makes it clear Dylan is child of the 1940s and 1950s. The Beat literature of Allen Ginsburg and Jack Kerouac were important influences with their electrifying poetry that rocked 1950s America. Dylan also idolized Woody Guthrie and imitated him early in his career, moved on from him, but the spirit of Woody was always there. Those sources, however, are only scratching the surface.
The book's best chapter is on the making of Blonde on Blonde (1966), an example of the multitude of influences on Dylan, but also attests to his own genius. Recorded in 1965-66, Dylan informed his producer Bob Johnston he wanted "that thin wild mercury sound." In the summer of 1965 Dylan's Highway 61 Revisited (arguably his best ever) shattered the conventions of rock music and scored a top ten single with "Like a Rolling Stone." He spent the rest of 1965 touring with the Hawks (a.k.a. The Band) and wrote what became Blonde on Blonde. His life was moving at a frenetic pace and yet he managed to songs that were "meditations on desire, frailty, promises, boredom, hurt, envy, connections, connections missed, paranoia, and transcendent beauty," The sound of the album mixed elements of Chicago blues, folk, British pop, 1950s rock - all the while sounding completely original. The sessions in New York with the band were disappointing so at the suggestion of Johnson, Dylan recorded in Nashville with seasoned country musicians. The results were a spellbinding double album with surreal songs that literally sounded like it was 3AM. Lyrics like "the ghost of electricity howls in the bones of her face" marked new heights for Dylan.
Other parts of his career are given detailed analysis as well, especially Dylan's two folk albums of the early 1990s: Good As I've Been to You (1992) and World Gone Wrong (1993), which offered reinterpretations of now forgotten folk songs rooted in American history. Dylan recent triumphs, most notably Love and Theft (2001), helped mold Dylan's new perona as a world weary prophet. His recent albums draw on the rich history of American music, of which his recent Christmas album is a perfect example. At 70, Dylan also draws much controversy over the alleged plagiarism in his songwriting. Wilentz defends these charges by arguing folk artists steal from each other - it is an old tradition.
Tuesday, August 17, 2010
Book Review: Wilco: Learning How to Die by Greg Kot
As the segmentation of popular musical tastes continues on into the 21st century few bands have won as much acclaim and respect than Wilco. Despite receiving no airplay on mainstream radio their album sales have increased with each album. Jeff Tweedy, the founder and chief songwriter for Wilco, is often mentioned among the likes of Bob Dylan and Neil Young. Greg Kot, music critic for the Chicago Tribune, wrote Wilco: Learning How to Die, an account the band at a tumultuous time in their history. Learning How to Die is a fine book on the current state of the record business and a revealing portrait of Tweedy.
The story of Wilco begins in Bellville, Ill, a town in the middle of the Midwest. In the 1980s High school buddies Jay Farrar and Jeff Tweedy forged a friendship based on their love of music. Both grew up in the harsh economic realities that plagued the Midwest in 1980s (and persist into the present) and saw music as a way out. Together they formed Uncle Tupelo in 1987 and developed a sound that blended elements of punk, country, and folk. Their 1990 debut album, No Depression, was a collection of ragged tracks that created its own genre of "alt-country."
Uncle Tupelo came to prominence in the underground rock scene of the early 1990s, an era remembered for the "grunge" sound from Seattle. Unlike Nirvana, who's themes revolved around teen angst and outrage at corporate America, Uncle Tupelo wrote honest commentaries on the realities of American life. Their second LP, Still Feel Gone, dwelt on these themes in a more coherent set of songs. Tracks like "Gun" and "Looking for a Way Out" captured the banality and emptiness of rural life - minus the romanticism of Bruce Springsteen and more in tone with Sherwood Anderson's novel Winesburg, Ohio. Their next album, March 16-20 1992, was a set of acoustic tracks produced by REM guitarist Peter Buck, in an even deeper examination of American roots music. Kot goes into detail on the creative and personal tensions that befell Tweedy and Farrar during the making of their final album Anodyne (1993) when both began to write their songs separately.
In 1994, Farrar dissolved Uncle Tupelo and Tweedy formed Wilco. Their first album, A.M., was a swiftly recorded set of twangy rock tunes that received a mixed reaction. With no chance of getting played on the radio, the band toured incessantly and gradually built a fan base. The addition of multi-instrumentalist Jay Bennett gave Tweedy a new collaborator with whom he wrote some of his best songs. Wilco's second LP, Being There, marked a creative breakthrough, a double album that celebrated 1970s classic rock.
An ongoing theme in the book is personal travails of Tweedy as a suffering artist torn between domestic and career obligations. After Being There, Wilco embarked on grueling tours that left Tweedy psychologically drained and plagued with migraine headaches. Long absences from his family also took its toll - along with the usual travails of the road. During concerts, he took on a new persona, getting confrontational with audiences that didn't take to the music. Band members grew nervous about Tweedy's increasingly unpredictable behavior onstage. In 1998, Wilco was asked by British folk rock artist Billy Bragg to contribute music for unpublished Woody Guthrie songs. These recordings resulted in two albums Mermaid Avenue (1998) and the follow up Mermaid Avenue. II were well received despite recurring conflicts with Bragg.
The release of Summerteeth (1999) and Yankee Hotel Foxtrot (2002) marked new artistic heights for Wilco in the midst of conflicts with their record company and painful personnel changes. Summerteeth was a pure pop album with some of the most haunting lyrics in recent memory. Tweedy, worried the songs were too dark in the album's first cut, retreated to the studio with Bennett and added heavy overdubs. Disappointing sales led their label, Reprise, to demand a more "commercial" sounding album next time around.
The last part of the book revolves around the long recording history of Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, an even more experimental effort than Summerteeth. After Reprise rejected the album the band released songs on their website and it quickly generated a buzz. Meanwhile, Tweedy replaced drummer Ken Coomer with Glenn Kotche. After the album's completion Bennett was also dismissed (all of which is chronicled in the Sam Jones documentary I am Trying to Break Your Heart) Kot is critical of Tweedy's less than diplomatic handling of these changes, but this all falls to the cliches of rock band politics. Eventually, the album was released on Nonesuch records and proved that music with substance could find an audience in an age dominated by five media companies. Despite all the turmoil, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is an amazing album. Although recorded before 9/11, the dark atmosphere of the album fit the country's mood. Tracks like "Jesus Ect"., "War on War," and "Ashes of American Flags" are filled with cryptic lyrics and a dark foreboding that hard times are ahead - with faint glimmers of hope
Fans of Wilco will enjoy this book since the author is a real fan. Earlier, I mentioned this was an up close account in the best since of the term since it avoids going into cheap tabloid territory. It would've been nice to learn a little more about Tweedy's songwriting process and his literary influences. Also, Jay Farrar leaves the narrative far too soon, a figure just as compelling as Tweedy. For insights into the current state of the record business the book is first rate.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5j2ykHinIPg&feature=related - Wilco performs "War on War" on Late Show with David Letterman
The story of Wilco begins in Bellville, Ill, a town in the middle of the Midwest. In the 1980s High school buddies Jay Farrar and Jeff Tweedy forged a friendship based on their love of music. Both grew up in the harsh economic realities that plagued the Midwest in 1980s (and persist into the present) and saw music as a way out. Together they formed Uncle Tupelo in 1987 and developed a sound that blended elements of punk, country, and folk. Their 1990 debut album, No Depression, was a collection of ragged tracks that created its own genre of "alt-country."
Uncle Tupelo came to prominence in the underground rock scene of the early 1990s, an era remembered for the "grunge" sound from Seattle. Unlike Nirvana, who's themes revolved around teen angst and outrage at corporate America, Uncle Tupelo wrote honest commentaries on the realities of American life. Their second LP, Still Feel Gone, dwelt on these themes in a more coherent set of songs. Tracks like "Gun" and "Looking for a Way Out" captured the banality and emptiness of rural life - minus the romanticism of Bruce Springsteen and more in tone with Sherwood Anderson's novel Winesburg, Ohio. Their next album, March 16-20 1992, was a set of acoustic tracks produced by REM guitarist Peter Buck, in an even deeper examination of American roots music. Kot goes into detail on the creative and personal tensions that befell Tweedy and Farrar during the making of their final album Anodyne (1993) when both began to write their songs separately.
![]() |
Jay Bennett and Jeff Tweedy |
An ongoing theme in the book is personal travails of Tweedy as a suffering artist torn between domestic and career obligations. After Being There, Wilco embarked on grueling tours that left Tweedy psychologically drained and plagued with migraine headaches. Long absences from his family also took its toll - along with the usual travails of the road. During concerts, he took on a new persona, getting confrontational with audiences that didn't take to the music. Band members grew nervous about Tweedy's increasingly unpredictable behavior onstage. In 1998, Wilco was asked by British folk rock artist Billy Bragg to contribute music for unpublished Woody Guthrie songs. These recordings resulted in two albums Mermaid Avenue (1998) and the follow up Mermaid Avenue. II were well received despite recurring conflicts with Bragg.
The release of Summerteeth (1999) and Yankee Hotel Foxtrot (2002) marked new artistic heights for Wilco in the midst of conflicts with their record company and painful personnel changes. Summerteeth was a pure pop album with some of the most haunting lyrics in recent memory. Tweedy, worried the songs were too dark in the album's first cut, retreated to the studio with Bennett and added heavy overdubs. Disappointing sales led their label, Reprise, to demand a more "commercial" sounding album next time around.
The last part of the book revolves around the long recording history of Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, an even more experimental effort than Summerteeth. After Reprise rejected the album the band released songs on their website and it quickly generated a buzz. Meanwhile, Tweedy replaced drummer Ken Coomer with Glenn Kotche. After the album's completion Bennett was also dismissed (all of which is chronicled in the Sam Jones documentary I am Trying to Break Your Heart) Kot is critical of Tweedy's less than diplomatic handling of these changes, but this all falls to the cliches of rock band politics. Eventually, the album was released on Nonesuch records and proved that music with substance could find an audience in an age dominated by five media companies. Despite all the turmoil, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is an amazing album. Although recorded before 9/11, the dark atmosphere of the album fit the country's mood. Tracks like "Jesus Ect"., "War on War," and "Ashes of American Flags" are filled with cryptic lyrics and a dark foreboding that hard times are ahead - with faint glimmers of hope
Fans of Wilco will enjoy this book since the author is a real fan. Earlier, I mentioned this was an up close account in the best since of the term since it avoids going into cheap tabloid territory. It would've been nice to learn a little more about Tweedy's songwriting process and his literary influences. Also, Jay Farrar leaves the narrative far too soon, a figure just as compelling as Tweedy. For insights into the current state of the record business the book is first rate.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5j2ykHinIPg&feature=related - Wilco performs "War on War" on Late Show with David Letterman
Wednesday, July 14, 2010
Book Review: The Dharma Bums by Jack Kerouac
In 1957, the NY Times declared Jack Kerouac (1922-1968) the voice of his generation after the publication of On the Road. The Dharma Bums came out the following year and failed to win the literary world over. While similar in spirit to On the Road, The Dharma Bums is more spiritual. By the late 1950s, Kerouac, already a legendary figure among the beats, was enamored with Buddhism. For Kerouac, Eastern religion had the potential to inspire younger people searching for an identity in the uneasy splendor that was post war America. Now, over fifty years after its publication, it is credited with sparking the New Age movement.
The story centers around two characters and the people they meet. The narrator is Ray, an aspiring poet, and Japhy, a larger than life poet/Buddhist/zen master. Japhy is based on Gary Snyder (1930- ), a poet who lived in a Buddhist monastery and later associate of the beats. Like Dean Moriarty in On the Road, there is an otherworldly, messianic quality to the character. Ray is in awe of Japhy and aspires to emulate him. For a book about Buddhism, however, we learn very little about the religion itself. Kerouac throws out anecdotes and quotes from famous gurus, but it all feels like a joke the reader isn't in on.
The "story" revolves around trying to find some form of meaning in the consumerist, suburbanite society that America had become. Although both characters have a hedonistic streak, Ray's drinking eventually alienates Japhy. This sadly mirrored the path Kerouac followed after he achieved fame. This gives the book a melancholy vibe at the end. But the romanticism in the story, in particular the joy and grandeur of climbing a mountain (the novel's best section) is a joy to read. Like any Kerouac work it is an experience and although you aren't quite sure what happened - you know something happened.
The story centers around two characters and the people they meet. The narrator is Ray, an aspiring poet, and Japhy, a larger than life poet/Buddhist/zen master. Japhy is based on Gary Snyder (1930- ), a poet who lived in a Buddhist monastery and later associate of the beats. Like Dean Moriarty in On the Road, there is an otherworldly, messianic quality to the character. Ray is in awe of Japhy and aspires to emulate him. For a book about Buddhism, however, we learn very little about the religion itself. Kerouac throws out anecdotes and quotes from famous gurus, but it all feels like a joke the reader isn't in on.
The "story" revolves around trying to find some form of meaning in the consumerist, suburbanite society that America had become. Although both characters have a hedonistic streak, Ray's drinking eventually alienates Japhy. This sadly mirrored the path Kerouac followed after he achieved fame. This gives the book a melancholy vibe at the end. But the romanticism in the story, in particular the joy and grandeur of climbing a mountain (the novel's best section) is a joy to read. Like any Kerouac work it is an experience and although you aren't quite sure what happened - you know something happened.
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
Book Review: Libra by Don Delillo
Libra, by Don Delillo, is a work of fiction surrounding the assassination of John F. Kennedy. Lee Harvey Oswald is the novel's protagonist. Libra is not so much an attempt to set the facts straight about the assassination, but a study of how individuals influence the course of history. Everyday there are countless numbers of amateur historians and conspiracy theorists devote their lives to making sense of what happened on that November day in Dallas. Libra is a wild ride through conspiracies upon other conspiracies that takes the reader through a labyrinth in a search for truth of some kind.
The story is told through two separate time lines that converge in the final act. One narrative follows Oswald at various points in his life. The other timeline follows the conspirators as they formulate their plans. The historical context for the plot begins with the Bay of Pigs invasion. In April 1961, only three months into his presidency, President Kennedy approved a CIA operation to overthrow Fidel Castro's regime in Cuba. A force of Cuban exiles were ready to lead the invasion with American air support that Kennedy decided to pull at the last minute. The entire operation was a debacle and the military and the intelligence community never forgave Kennedy. Cuba became an obsession with them and the primary impetus for the attempt on President Kennedy's life. Delillo follows a renegade group within the CIA that covertly planned a failed assassination attempt and then blame it on Fidel Castro.
The novel picks in the sections that deal with Oswald. We first meet him as a teenager living in a Bronx tenement with his mother. A loner and often the target of bullies who mock his southern accent, he took refuge in the writings of communist revolutionaries Karl Marx and Leon Trotsky. He blamed the capitalist system for the humiliating conditions his family had to accept. At 17, he enlisted in the marines and an undistinguished service record. While he was stationed in Japan he began to learn Russian and made plans to defect. Why did Oswald enlist? Delillo portrays him as a conscientious soldier who wanted to learn firsthand the psychology behind an oppressive system. After wounding himself in a gun accident he was discharged.
Upon arriving in Russia in 1959, Oswald offered his services to the Soviets. They gave him a cool reception and suspected he was a double agent. Nevertheless, he offered them information on America's U-2 spy program of which he knew little. Unsure of what to do with him they set him up with a factory job in Minsk. While, there he meets his wife and grows disillusioned with the Soviet system. Unhappy with his social status he manages to emigrate back to the United States. Delillo paints complex portrait of Oswald, a tendency towards violence, intelligent, a fixation with guns, and determined to accomplish something important.
Every character in the book is plagued witth paranoia. They all believed they will change the course of history and yet all feel powerless before the forces that will determine their fate. This contradiction is best expressed in the David Ferrie character, a hard line anti-communist and amateur astrologer (among other things). Later in the novel he forms a bizarre friendship with Oswald and offers an analysis of the conspiracy:
This sets the stage the novel's final act as the two lines begin to converge.
In my opinion this was the weakest section of the book. Without offering plot spoilers, the scenario Delillo imagines is as plausible as any. But it all seems superfluous since the we already know what happened, the question is how it happened. The final fifty pages follow another oddball Jack Ruby, who would shoot Oswald three days after the killing of Kennedy. Ruby, a Dallas nightclub owner who was outraged about the assassination took it upon himself to save the city's reputation. Since Ruby owed thousands to the mob he was caught up in the nexus of mobsters, Cuban exiles, and the CIA - his story is an amusing coda to a very dark novel.
As a prominent post-modern writer Delillo avoids trying to offer answers about the Kennedy assassination. Post-modernist historians argue that all works of history only exist in the historian's mind. It is impossible to ever reconstruct a historical event. There a few flash forwards in the story to CIA archivist in the late 1970s attempting to write the official history and overwhelming number of contradictory facts and strange coincidences left him completely lost. From hindsight the attacks of 9/11 continue to haunt this generation, but it will never captivate people like the Kennedy conspiracy. This was something that happened internally and our fascination may tells us more about ourselves than we care to know.
The story is told through two separate time lines that converge in the final act. One narrative follows Oswald at various points in his life. The other timeline follows the conspirators as they formulate their plans. The historical context for the plot begins with the Bay of Pigs invasion. In April 1961, only three months into his presidency, President Kennedy approved a CIA operation to overthrow Fidel Castro's regime in Cuba. A force of Cuban exiles were ready to lead the invasion with American air support that Kennedy decided to pull at the last minute. The entire operation was a debacle and the military and the intelligence community never forgave Kennedy. Cuba became an obsession with them and the primary impetus for the attempt on President Kennedy's life. Delillo follows a renegade group within the CIA that covertly planned a failed assassination attempt and then blame it on Fidel Castro.
The novel picks in the sections that deal with Oswald. We first meet him as a teenager living in a Bronx tenement with his mother. A loner and often the target of bullies who mock his southern accent, he took refuge in the writings of communist revolutionaries Karl Marx and Leon Trotsky. He blamed the capitalist system for the humiliating conditions his family had to accept. At 17, he enlisted in the marines and an undistinguished service record. While he was stationed in Japan he began to learn Russian and made plans to defect. Why did Oswald enlist? Delillo portrays him as a conscientious soldier who wanted to learn firsthand the psychology behind an oppressive system. After wounding himself in a gun accident he was discharged.
Upon arriving in Russia in 1959, Oswald offered his services to the Soviets. They gave him a cool reception and suspected he was a double agent. Nevertheless, he offered them information on America's U-2 spy program of which he knew little. Unsure of what to do with him they set him up with a factory job in Minsk. While, there he meets his wife and grows disillusioned with the Soviet system. Unhappy with his social status he manages to emigrate back to the United States. Delillo paints complex portrait of Oswald, a tendency towards violence, intelligent, a fixation with guns, and determined to accomplish something important.
Every character in the book is plagued witth paranoia. They all believed they will change the course of history and yet all feel powerless before the forces that will determine their fate. This contradiction is best expressed in the David Ferrie character, a hard line anti-communist and amateur astrologer (among other things). Later in the novel he forms a bizarre friendship with Oswald and offers an analysis of the conspiracy:
Think of two parallel lines . . . One is the life of Lee Harvey Oswald. One is the conspiracy to kill the president. What bridges the space between them? What makes a connection inevitable? There is a third line. It comes out of dreams, visions, intuitions, prayers out of the deepest layers of the self.
This sets the stage the novel's final act as the two lines begin to converge.
In my opinion this was the weakest section of the book. Without offering plot spoilers, the scenario Delillo imagines is as plausible as any. But it all seems superfluous since the we already know what happened, the question is how it happened. The final fifty pages follow another oddball Jack Ruby, who would shoot Oswald three days after the killing of Kennedy. Ruby, a Dallas nightclub owner who was outraged about the assassination took it upon himself to save the city's reputation. Since Ruby owed thousands to the mob he was caught up in the nexus of mobsters, Cuban exiles, and the CIA - his story is an amusing coda to a very dark novel.
As a prominent post-modern writer Delillo avoids trying to offer answers about the Kennedy assassination. Post-modernist historians argue that all works of history only exist in the historian's mind. It is impossible to ever reconstruct a historical event. There a few flash forwards in the story to CIA archivist in the late 1970s attempting to write the official history and overwhelming number of contradictory facts and strange coincidences left him completely lost. From hindsight the attacks of 9/11 continue to haunt this generation, but it will never captivate people like the Kennedy conspiracy. This was something that happened internally and our fascination may tells us more about ourselves than we care to know.
Monday, May 31, 2010
Movie Review: The Trials of Henry Kissinger
Voltaire once described history as nothing more than a tableau of crime and misfortune - a view the 20th century proved correct. The Trials of Henry Kissinger is a polemical documentary that argues that former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger was guilty of war crimes perpetuated by the Nixon and Ford administrations. Based on a book by the iconoclastic journalist Christopher Hitchens, the film has commentary from many former aides, journalists, and biographers. I applaud the film's critical look at American foreign policy, but it betrays its premise because it resembles a show trial and not a fair trial.
For a time, back in the 1970s, Henry Kissinger made international diplomacy attractive. As National Security Adviser to Richard Nixon (1969-74) and later Secretary of State to Nixon and Ford (73-77) Kissinger literally shaped American diplomacy in the 1970s. Before becoming an international celebrity who dated young actresses he was hardly known outside academic circles. At the age of 13, Kissinger's family, being Jewish, emigrated from Nazi Germany and settled in New York City. After serving in the Second World War Kissinger studied international relations at Harvard and became an academic star. In the 1950s and 1960s wrote a few bestseller, most famously, Limited War and Nuclear Weapons In 1968, the president-elect Richard Nixon appointed Kissinger as his National Security Adviser.
The foreign policy accomplishments during the Kissinger years are substantial: negotiating an end to America's involvement in Vietnam (but not the Vietnam War), the opening of China, arms control with the still terrifying Soviet Union, and shuttle diplomacy in the Middle East in the chaotic months following the 1973 Yom Kippur War. They called it detente, policies designed to reduce Cold War tensions. The documentary focused on three specific areas: Cambodia, Chile, and East Timor.
Cambodia. In early 1969 the Nixon administration began clandestine bombing campaigns on Cambodia, a sovereign nation, to strike at North Vietnam's supply line. By 1970, with the peace negotiations going nowhere, Nixon announced on television a ground invasion of Cambodia by U.S. forces. Members of Kissinger's staff resigned over the decision and the campuses went aflame. Forty years ago this month four students were killed by the National Guard at Kent St. University. The Cambodian invasion ended several months later with mixed results, but left conditions favorable for radical elements to take over the government - the Khmer Rouge. They were a radical ultra left wing faction who seized power in 1975 and forced the entire population into the countryside. Over one million died in the genocide. The film places the blame squarely on Kissinger for creating the conditions for the atrocities in Cambodia.
The other areas covered, Chile and East Timor, are far more complicated. In 1973, military coup in Chile overthrew Salvador Allende, a Marxist who the administration viewed as another Castro. Evidence that come clearly shows the CIA played a part overthrowing Allende, aided by American companies who were threatened by the regime. East Timor, a former colony of the Portuguese Empire, was invaded by Indonesia in 1975 and absorbed into that country (in 2002 East Timor gained its independence). The Ford administration provided weapons to Indonesia in their brutal crackdown on East Timor. For these crimes, should Henry Kissinger face prosecution from international courts for crimes against humanity?
In saying that, I admire Hitchens. He is one of the great commentators writing in the English speaking world today. His frequent appearances in television contain more wit that all the godawful commentary infesting the cable news airwaves. In the past, Hitchens has taken on Mother Theresa, Bill Clinton, and lately all organized religion. The mainstream media's coverage of American foreign policy is banal and we need journalists like Hitchens to bring light to certain facts. By his standards, however, every administration since Truman should face the docket. It is unlikely that any American will in the near future, and that hypocrisy is a problem. But for America to have a more democratic society, more discussion on foreign policy is something desperately needed.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)